Blog about Russia, Soviet Union, Olympics and artistic gymnastics. News and interviews on gymnastics champions, coaches and competitions.

Saturday, August 4, 2012

Score breakdowns - women's all around and team

I know that many of the stattos out there are just dying to play around with some full results from the team and all around competitions.  Sadly, no judges breakdown.  Well, here we are : the gymnastics results site has published them.  Thank you!!  You can find team results here and all around results here.  See screen grabs below for ease of reference.  And discuss, please!!







Let's not forget the qualification results:



Enjoy! 

Friday, August 3, 2012

Judging Komova and Douglas - like comparing the Mariinsky Theatre ... and a Disco


Lupita translates an article about the women's all around from today's Sovietski Sport.

OLYMPICS OR LAS VEGAS CASINO?

Aliya and Vika waited for Viktoria�s score for her floor, which closed the AA competition. Gabriella Douglas was completely alone, biting her lips.

Douglas was not sure of anything, except that Aliya Mustafina, who stayed in gymnastics like a heroine, had won bronze and Komova�  In this instant it was decided to be, or not to be.  To be Olympic Champion, or not to be Olympic Champion.

It�s over.  Vika drops her head on Aliya�s shoulder.  The judges have decided: Douglas!

I choose the sentence "Douglas has been named Olympic AA champion".  I can explain when this happened.  It was not when Komova didn�t land her Amanar vault well.

Her mistake on vault was not fatal.  It was still possible to make it up. They just didn�t allow her to do so.

Douglas performed with pleasure and with luck.  She was overscored for her uneven bars routine.  Later they increased her �capital� on beam.  It was enough for a new American victory.  After bars Komova could have not fought.  In her first World championships in Tokyo she was underscored on Wieber�s behalf.  At her first Olympics, on Douglas� behalf.  The Americans change, the judges� alliances remain the same.  And they are very smart in the way that they build up their strategy.

Valentina Rodionenko mentioned those alliances during the spring.  Let�s consider the judges on bars where Douglas was crowned.  There wasn�t a single American judge.  UK, Puerto Rico, Australia.  That�s enough.  Alliances working for the US include judges from South and North American, with Australia and the UK.


A gymnast can�t even upgrade her bars completely in a year.   But then, there is a miracle in two days!

One of the team�s coaches says nervously:  "All interviews after the final.  What?  Douglas? The judges know better".

I talk to Nastia Grishina who won silver with our team . I ask her the same question. What does she think about Douglas� score?  She just says: �Judges� stuff�.

Komova�s turn on beam. She�s not scared. She looks beautiful.

?liya Mustafina falls off beam, but thanks to a fantastic bar routine she overcomes the second American � Aleksandra Raisman - and wins bronze!  Her bronze is a genuine victory...


�Our girls, who perform elements from rhythmic gymnastics on floor, such as spins in vertical split, are standing and applauding.  Art on floor cannot compete with the art of fair scoring when necessary.

On bars Komova was far better than Douglas, they were equal on beam. To compare them on floor is similar to comparing Mariinsky Theatre and a disco.

Yet Komova loses to Douglas. This happens and it will happen until someone does something to prevent the Olympics from becoming a casino.

"I feel happy for Komova, she fought all over," says Aleksei Nemov, four time Olympic champion. "For me she deserves to be Olympic champion. Vika is beautiful, polished and she has unique elements, while Douglas is kind of ugly, excuse the vulgarity of my masculine phrase. I say what I think. This is my feeling, you see, but the judges saw this differently... we cannot blame Vika for anything. Let�s congratulate her and Aliya."



Biassed?  Yes.  As biassed as much of the 'neutral' gymnastics press.  As biassed as the 'objective' code ... as biassed as some of the 'fair' judges.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Komova should have won!

It was a very tight battle in the North Greenwich arena today, with American Gabby Douglas beating out Viktoria Komova by a mere 0.259 points (see results below) and the legendary Aliya Mustafina sealing her comeback from that career-threatening injury with a well deserved bronze medal. Yes, she suffered a fall from beam after her Arabian somersault but elsewhere she was at her best, a real endorsement of the work of the Russian coaches in nursing her back to almost-top form since that fateful day in 2011.

Komova had a faultless competition apart from a step on landing her Amanar vault. Frankly, she must feel utterly shattered after coming second once again by a very small margin to an American who was treated very generously by the judges. Komova soared and took every beam move to the max, rounding off with her rare double Arabian dismount in fine style; Douglas literally sidled along the beam, seeming frightened to take her feet off the apparatus for all but her somersaults. Komova was back to her junior form on floor, leaping, twisting and somersaulting with the most amazing power disguised as lightness, and dancing with all the confidence of a trained performer, while Douglas tiptoed and waved her arms in the air in what was a pale imitation of a floor routine.

Oh, and then there is bars; can anyone explain the .5 hike in Douglas's score compared to Tuesday's performance? Did she really improve her execution so much? Did she really manage to achieve better execution scores than both Mustafina and Komova?

Douglas was a worthy silver medallist, with significantly better line that we are used to from an American, but very poor choreography and not an all around champion by my measure, especially not against Komova at her best. Despite her step on vault Komova was the best today and should have won by rights. I don't like to listen to Russian coaches complaining about the marks, which I guess we are going to have to tolerate in coming days, but if the boot were on the other foot the gymternet would be alive with twitters, Facebook and blog posts by American coaches defending their gymnasts. The double standards are appalling. The FIG says it wants beautiful gymnastics and that the Amanar needs downgrading, then marks vault higher than ever before. Bars scores have favoured the American girls during both finals, being held down when they might help the Russian girls level during the team competition, and hiked during the all around when it favoured Douglas to do so.

Nevertheless, I will congratulate all the medallists for their fantastic performances today. It was by far the best all around competition I have seen in many years. And that bronze medal - well, it's worth more than its weight in gold. Kudos to Queen Mustafina, and commiserations to Tsarina Viktoria, who really should have been wearing the gold medal tonight.




Will there ever be another Olga?

Did you see Olga Korbut on TV earlier this week? There she sat, a big smile on her face, every bit the naughty little Munchkin we all knew back in 1972.  The gymnasts need to smile more, to be beautiful, and to entertain, she said.  I, and several others, wish alike.  It's 40 years since we have seen her like at the Olympics; yes, Nadia came four years later and entranced us with her steely perfection, but it was Olga who stole our hearts. 

Where will the next Olga come from?  Will there ever be another?  Perhaps not ... time has passed, we are all more media-savvy and cynical, athletes more contrived and less spontaneous, the sport's Code of Points denuded of the semantic subtleties of the unique, expressive artistry that the world found so enchanting. 

But sitting there, amongst the judges, is a woman who was once as charming and delightful as Olga could ever be ... a former gymnast who thanks to the vagaries of world politics and the sheer depth on her national team, was never seen at an Olympics ... FIG judge Oksana Omelianchyk-Ziurkalova, 1985 World Overall Champion, 1985 World Floor Champion, Soviet reserve at the 1988 Seoul Olympics, Soviet reserve at the 1984 Oloumoc Games, the Soviet 'alternative Olympics'.

I was sitting there, in the audience, during the 2001 World Championships in Ghent.  Oksana and a judging colleague had taken up a couple of seats in the row in front of me, and were conscientiously recording the uneven bars routines, checking their marks against those of the official judging panel.  In person, Omelianchik is as charming as on the floor; people came to shake her hand, always greeted with the greatest of courtesy and a big smile.  As she rose to leave the arena, the first bars of a gymnast's music rang out ... coincidentally, the first bars of Oksana's 1985/1986 floor routine.  I couldn't help but smile, and she quietly smiled too.






Later today, in the all around final, Oksana will be an execution judge on vault - you can see the judges' assignments below.  Remember her floor routine as you watch today's final.


Other former gymnasts judging at today's Games include 1972 Olympian Antonina Koshel (Floor), Romania's Anca Grigoras (floor), Czech Republic's Hana Liskarova (Ricna), Hungary's Szusanna Kalmar.  The superior jury includes President Nelli Kim (1976 and 1980 Olympian, 1979 World Champion) and uneven bars supervisor, 1972 Olympian Liubov Burda-Andrianova.

Wednesday, August 1, 2012

WAG All Around - start list

Viktoria Komova in Tuesday's team final, where she won a silver medal.  Courtesy RGF
The start list for tomorrow's all around final in women's gymnastics is available here.  Both Viktoria and Aliya begin on vault, in the same group as Gabby Douglas, Alexandra Raisman, Vanessa Ferrari and Deng Linlin.

Good luck to all gymnasts - I hope you all have a good competition and I look forward t


Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Aliya Mustafina - I'll continue training after the Games

Aliya Mustafina credits her involvement in sport to her family, especially her father, Fargat Mustafin
Well, by now you will all know that the Russian team won a silver medal in the team competition, their best result since 2000.  They were beautiful, but suffered more errors than they would have wanted to, and were rather distressed about this at the end of the competition.  However, silver is a good result for them and I hope they can raise themselves for all around and event finals where there is much to fight for.  The American girls looked really good on this occasion, producing some consistent gymnastics to take first place absolutely convincingly, and I was delighted to see the Romanians take bronze thanks to the hard work of coaches Belu and Bitang and the gymnasts.  You can find the full results here.

Aliya Mustafina has had a particularly hard - but ultimately rewarding - 18 months, recovering from the career threatening injury she incurred at the Berlin European Championships in spring 2011.  She has shone on both occasions she has appeared in London; she is the spiritual centre of this team and I so hope she can do well in the individual finals for which she has qualified.  Now, you can read a few of Aliya's thoughts as she prepared for these Games, translated by Lupita from an original Russian language article that appeared at Russian Gymnastics' sponsors VTB's website.

Aliya Mustafina came to sport because of family circumstances.   Her father, Farhat Mustafin was a bronze medallist in wrestling at the 1976 Olympics, who�s now a coach.  He says that his wife and he didn�t plan to bring up champions. They just wanted their children to be busy doing something.  They thought: �If they practice sport until they�re 12, they�ll be healthy and when they�ll start serious studies, we'll let them leave sport, and they�ll study.  We don�t want the kids to be in the street.  I took the smaller one when she was going to the kindergarten, and her mum took Aliya to an evening training.  When she was nine, Alya went with her sister.  Although Nelka is two years younger, she remembered her way very well�.   Aliya Mustafina, twice World champion, has gone through the glory and pain of elite sport.  Athletes don�t have free time before the Olympics.  Yet Aliya found half an tour to talk with the correspondent of VTB.
 
� You've just finished school and you are leaving for the Olympics.
� Yes, I managed to combine my studies and my training.  Obviously, I�m happy that the exams are over. I�ll have to decide what I�ll study later.  But of course I�ll decide that after the Games.

� What is more difficult right now?  Waiting?  Or would you prefer the Olympics to begin a little later?
 
� No, it�s difficult to wait for the time when we will perform, when we go into the Olympic podium.  The most difficult thing will be in the UK.  We have to work over three weeks, it�s important not to be betrayed by your feet, your muscles, your nerves. 

� What are your current feelings: "Wow, we feel so strong!" or "we�ll soon peak"? 

� No, so far it�s not �WOW�. These last days are essential to polish everything. 

� ?liya, tell me: �How many times did you have to chase away those thoughts during the past weeks: "What did I get involved in all this for?  I could live a quieter life!"

� ?hat never happened to me! On the contrary, I understand that little time is left.  We need to be patient for a while, to compete at the Olympics and later everything will be easier. 

� Is it easier to compete than to make a decision?

� The Olympics are the most difficult competition.
� Once I asked your father: you were an athlete, your wife is a physicist.  In your family you must have cult for sport and physical sciences.  He answered: the cult of the family...

� For me, family is family with no other words to define it.  ?y mum, my dad, my sister. Obviously, my love for sport comes from my dad.  Although he didn�t fix important goals for me.  Sometimes he said; �Come on, Aliya, if you train hard, you�ll become World Champion".  I don�t know if he believed it or not. My mum and my dad never waited for hours in the gym, as other parents did.  I fell instantly in love with gymnastics.  I liked the Swedish bench, trampoline, later bars � When I was small, everything was interesting and I always had fun. ? t school my favourite subjects were physics and maths.  They are always easy for me because they are interesting. And I understand many things. 

This surprises many people. Where does the interest lie

� How could physics not be interesting?!  How nature�s laws work!  My mother is a teacher.  Before starting the 7th grade, when I started physics, I began to read the textbook�  Since then, physics is my favourite subject. 

� The girls on the team always said that you are able to count the score you needed. Is it true?

� Of course. It�s pure matsh. And, by the way, I am not the only one.  One shouldn�t think that at Krugloye we don�t see or do anything else.

� We can�t stop life. You spend yours at  Krugloye.

� I feel very comfortable there.  Obviously, I seldom see my family.  After the important competitions, we get a free week, but we are seldom home.  The first thing I do is to go to my school. I meet my friends. We have time to go to the cinema and for a walk.  We spend the whole year at Krugloye, I have friends there and other friends in Moscow. In Moscow my friends are not gymnasts.

� Don�t you get tired of elite sport?  You cried more for a year than in your whole life.  It was an important year for you. Your recovery after injury was very long�

� No, I can�t say that I cried for a whole year.  I�m growing older.

� Experiences build your character. Do you feel the changes yourself?

� External and internal changes.  I have grown taller, put on weight.  And I have begun to work in a different way in each event. My previous gymnastics was more like children�s gymnastics.  After the injury, I began to grow taller. 

� One could say that you suffered from the injury.

� Yes, no doubt.  It was more difficult to work.  Perhaps because I am still not used to my new body???? I became more womanly and this is also something new. 

� Do you feel that you preserved yourself after the injury?

� No, I never felt this.  I worked as normal.  It was useful that I came back immediately to Krugloye.  Five days after the surgery I went to the gym.  I could have waited somewhere else, but I went to the gym with my team-mates, they did their job while I did conditioning and helped them�  Now I want the Olympics to start.  And I want to compete, to fight�.  Don�t say that these days are horrible, the last ones. They are useful to polish things. 

� I understand that it�s not the best moment to ask this question, but do you ever think that you will train for another Olympic cycle?

� Yes, I do. In fact, we still have to finish this cycle. And later. Perhaps it will become obvious.

� When you were recovering, competition got stronger in the national team? Can competition be an irritation?

� No, my goal is to help the team. Because, whatever you do, you compete two days only for the team and then begin the individual competitions, performing the best I can. This is the goal.

� Everyone says that you are a perfectionist (a maximalist????).

� I�ll suffer, but I hope everything will turn out OK..

� Alexander Alexandrov used to say that your main quality is confidence. �She is able to concentrate in a competition. Even if the day before she doesn�t hit in the gym, and cries with impotence, she competes and she is able to struggle".

�� You know, after I became World Champion, I  as often asked if something had changed about me.  In fact nothing changed.  Of course I know that Svetlana Khorkina had been World Champion many years before.  It was nice to be compared to her, but Khorhina is Khorkina and I am Mustafina. I want to leave something of my own in gymnastics.
 
 
 

WAG final start lists

Aliya Mustafina competes on beam in qualifying on Sunday.  FIG





You will be able to find start lists for this afternoon's women's team final here.

Russia begin on vault, alongside the American team.  Their working order at present stands as follows :

Vault : Mustafina, Komova, Paseka
Bars : Grishina, Mustafina, Komova
Beam : Mustafina, Komova, Afanasyeva
Floor : Mustafina, Grishina, Afanasyeva


You see, this team begins and ends with Mustafina and Afanasyeva ...












Ksenia Afanasyeva during podium training.  FIG

Russian men finish 6th in fiery Olympic final

Denis Ablyazin on floor at this year's Russia Cup.  Courtesy of the RFG

As Britain recorded an historic first medal in the men's gymnastics team competition at the North Greenwich arena yesterday, Russia struggled to fulfill their potential.  With falls on pommels, vault and parallel bars they finished in sixth place, with a team total almost three points lower than that achieved in qualifying.

This must surely be a learning experience for a very young team who have every right to believe that things will turn out better in the end if only they can keep up the work ethic that has seen them make such strong improvements since 2008.

In that time Russia have also had to grapple with a change in the world order which has seen countries such as Britain, Germany, USA and, now, the exciting Ukraine develop into a strong second league in world gymnastics behind the leading crew of Japan and China.  Men's gymnastics in many ways is now a preferable experience to the women's sport for its vibrancy and depth of competition.  It is a pleasure to watch these calmly modest daredevils at work.  Gymnasts must be some of the most sporting, courteous athletes in the world; just look at the way that Uchimura handled himself in the midst of that judging debacle.  See how the Ukrainians reacted to the loss of their bronze medal, the British to their rapid turnaround from silver to bronze.  If the sport is ever let down, it is usually by an official.  The men's sport is so much less shrill,  emotional and contrived than women's gymnastics : the true Olympic spirit of participation, international relations and friendship is alive and kicking.

It's not the end of the line for the Russians; they have gymnasts qualified to finals in the all around and in all events.  They'll live to fight another day.

Read the full results here.

Monday, July 30, 2012

Artistic gymnastics is alive, well and Russian!

Viktoria Komova, watched by podium coach Maria Nazarova yesterday

Artistic gymnastics is all about amplitude, flight, grace and elegance, expression.  The way the gymnast leaps and somersaults and twists in the air, performing acts of incredible strength and skill but making them look like effortless works of art. The way the gymnast pauses mid-air and makes complex movements with, apparently, all the time in the world.  Let's call it virtuosity. 

In the North Greenwich arena, yesterday afternoon, spectators were treated to a brilliant exposition on the sport of gymnastics by a team of feisty young Russians who have come to London determined to make their mark in the history of the sport.  It is twenty years since the collapse of the Soviet Union, whose gymnastics legacy they embrace. The sport has since moved on, and is now principally the domain of bouncy, synthetically smiling teenagers who bow down only to the sport's Code of Points and their coaches' instructions. For them, the sport might just as well be renamed 'sporting gymnastics' (ironically, a direct translation of the sport's name in the Russian language).  But for the Russians, the requirement is still 'artistic gymnastics'.  They just can't wash the need to be beautiful out of their perfectly tinted hair. 

Russia is a thorn in the sport's side in this respect, even if the international governing body, the FIG, recently declared 'We are missing out on the beauty of gymnastics'.  The team's tendency to take risks and stretch every move to the max - ('amplitude' - watch Viktoria Komova in particular) - runs directly against the current sporting maxim of reliability and consistency encouraged by a lifeless, one dimensional Code that provides little scope to reward artistry.   It also has a tendency to provoke the kind of errors that incur deductions large enough to deprive them of gold medals.  Compromise is not a word in the Russians' vocabulary.   1992 Olympic Beam Champion Tatiana Lyssenko recently explained the Soviet maxim that has become so much a part of Russia's gymnastics ethos:

'No matter how safe you play it, there�s never a guarantee that you will not make a mistake. And taking risks like that was part of our team philosophy: the idea that if you could do something, you should do it�you should show it to the world. It wasn�t about playing a game of points or determining how to use the Code to your advantage. It was about showing the best gymnastics that you could in a pure sense..'

So when they come to a competition like the Olympics, Russia's competitive status is frequently a bit questionable, The errors that are often induced by their take-it-to-the-max approach are penalised by the judges, but without a corresponding bonus being applied for the added artistry and risk they bring, that induces a higher likelihood of error.  Just because they are trying to do more, and represent the sport in all its dimensions. It's not fair.  It's almost as though the FIG would rather not enjoy the artistry of gymnastics any more, despite paying lip service to the opposite view. 

How many errors can you see? - USA gymnast Alexandra Raisman in flight
The reality of the situation can be seen a little more clearly by observing what is happening currently to the American team, where team stalwart Alexandra Raisman has controversially ousted 2011 World Champion Jordyn Wieber from the all around final.  Many are characterising this as a weakness in the sporting rules that limit participation in finals to two gymnasts per country.  This is certainly one way of looking at the problem.  Another way of thinking is that the FIG and what I call the American school of gymnastics has finally eaten itself and got the gymnastics it deserves.  Raisman has avoided penalty for her many gymnastic deficiencies for too long.  The Code ignores her complete dearth of artistry and amplitude; it is blind to the countless errors in form that characterise her work but which are presumably too countless to begin deducting for.  The fact that she has qualified for floor final in first place is a travesty; even from several rows back in the North Greenwich arena her pagoda legs in tumbles, lack of toe point, and mangled lines in flight throughout were glaringly obvious.  But Wieber, a much better gymnast, made errors such as stepping out of the area, ones that have a specific and clear deduction in the Code, that Raisman did not suffer.  It was easier just to stick to the Code, to avoid making a value judgement and giving Raisman the lower scores she deserved, and so America, the FIG, the world has ended up with monstrous gymnastics at the top of the sport. 

There is a ground swell of support for the concept of artistry, and against the FIG's Code of Points, amongst gym fans and commentators, although not many will say so publicly.  After all, the athletic Americans, the enthusiastic Brits, the energetic Canadians, all stand a better chance of winning if artistry is side lined.  Some of their gymnasts might make a nod in its direction, but their teams are generally more athlete than artist, and it's easier to coach if there are strict, quantifiable rules rather than the qualitative, subjective guidelines that are necessarily a part of an artistic sport.

Anastasia Grishina in a daring somersault during yesterday's qualifications

So the only way that Russia will win any gold in the women's gymnastics competition in London this week will be by complying with the judges', and the Code's, limitations and adding sufficient athleticism and reliability to their already recognised arsenal of virtuosity.  They will not have to be a little bit better than their closest rivals (probably America) if they are to win ... they will have to be out of this world.

In yesterday's qualifications, they weren't quite out of this world ... but  getting there.  And with the American team looking a bit rattled, and riddled with internal tensions that result from their largely individualist training system, it's possible that the fight for gold might be tighter than many have predicted. 

This Russian team is spirited, strong and close.  The personalities are intriguing.  Their performances are solid, beautiful and artistically diverse.  They put the air-kissing, cosmetically smiling, endlessly rehearsed American team to shame with their spontaneity and mutual concern.  They deliver an arsenal of difficulty and upgrades that the world hasn't seen from them before, but still have more in the tank.  And then there is the charisma.

Ksenia Afanasyeva performs to a rendition of the theme from James Bond

A key measure of any team's success, according to coach Leonid Arkayev, who presided at the top of Soviet and Russian gymnastics for over 30 years, is the breadth of its involvement in competition - has your team qualified competitors to every event final?  Just as this was true for the resurgent Russian men, it has proved true for the women, who really did themselves justice yesterday.  They finished a relatively close second to the Americans in the team standings (181.463 to 180.429) despite a wobbly floor routine from Komova and a less than usually brilliant bars routine from youngster Anastasia Grishina, who was looking a bit strained at her first Olympics.  Their top two gymnasts - Komova and Mustafina - finished in first and fifth places respectively in the all around, and look likely to compete for medals there.  We also have a host of Russians represented in the all important event finals : it will be a surprise, therefore, if Russia repeats its awful experience of four years ago, and walks away from these Games empty-handed.

Aliya Mustafina, watched by youngster Grishina on beam yesterday
You can read the full results of the competition here; and for ease of reference, here are details of the Russian qualifiers to event finals :

  • Maria Paseka landed the all important Amanar vault and added to it with a Mustafina, qualifying in third place for a vaulting event final that no one really expected for Russia!
  • Viktoria Komova and Aliya Mustafina qualified for uneven bars final
  • Viktoria Komova and Ksenia Afanasyeva really shone on beam, finishing in second and 7th place and hence qualifying for the final there.
  • Aliya Mustafina will join Ksenia Afanasyeva in a floor final that will surely be a highlight for Russian fans.


Upgrades shown by the Russians include a double-double on floor from Grishina; a double double dismount on bars from Komova (and Mustafina was back to sticking her 1.5 twisting double dismount); Amanars from both Komova and Paseka;  a double Arabian dismount on beam from Komova.  

Sadly, the Romanian team had a difficult qualifying round and finished fourth as a team, with many expected finals qualifications out of kilter, but I'm guessing that they will be much better tomorrow and might even compete for gold as a team if the top two teams have errors.  It was great to see the British team finish in 5th place, unprecedented for them, and home hero Beth Tweddle qualified for bars final in first place.

Good luck to all gymnasts in Tuesday's team final!!

Pictures are courtesy of the Russian Gymnastics Federation.