Blog about Russia, Soviet Union, Olympics and artistic gymnastics. News and interviews on gymnastics champions, coaches and competitions.

Thursday, June 27, 2013

Quick updates - Moscow Dynamo, Boguinskaia on Alexandrov and the Anadia Cup

High summer has hit and with it an uncharacteristically high load of features to write ... to keep things up to date I will provide some brief links here to all the latest news.


The historic Moscow Dynamo club, home to champions past and present including Emin Garibov, Sergei Kharkov, Natalia Ilienko, Olga Mostepanova, Tatiana Groshkova, Maria Goryunova and Nadezhda Ivanova, is being forced to transfer its operations for a minimum of three years to temporary facilities at the Olympiski stadium.  Dynamo's old building is being replaced by a brand new sporting facility funded by Russian sports sponsor, bank VTB, but the status of gymnastics within the new building is unconfirmed to date. 

This temporary arrangement is far from ideal.  At present it seems likely that the Club will not be able to stage the annual Voronin Cup which has become such an important part of the international gymnastics calendar.   Removal arrangements seem highly informal, with the club asking parents to help transfer equipment from the old gym to the Olympiski stadium.  The facilities at Olympiski are incomplete and unsuitable for a developed club like Dynamo, and much of the spirit and body of the club is now homeless.  Dynamo's elite gymnasts will transfer to train at Lake Krugloye, and the club will suspend recruitment of new gymnasts for three years while the new facilities become available.  

There has been an excellent blog on this subject by Natalia Kalugina.  There will be a longer piece on Dynamo Moscow shortly after the Universiade.

With many thanks to Vladimir Zaglada.


Svetlana Boguinskaia has given an excellent - hour long - interview to Gymcastic - make time to listen, it is fascinating.  Boguinskaia talks about her life in gymnastics past and present.  How did she intimidate the gymnasts she trained alongside as a tiny little girl?  What part did candy play in her training?  What was the difference between training in the Soviet Union, and America?  All of this is discussed - and there are some very interesting revelations about the reasons for Alexander Alexandrov's departure from Moscow.








On which subject, I should turn my attentions to the Russian WAG latest outing to the Anadia Cup in Portugal.  The Couch Gymnast has a full summary of the all the results of which the key one for Russian gymnastics watchers was a gold on bars from Anastasia Grishina.

This seems rather paltry reward for a young team so rich in talent and, one would assume, ambition.  The composition of Grishina, Rodionova, Baturina, Sosnitskaia was undoubtedly a B team led by a potential A teamer (Rodionova) and a potential World Champion (Grishina). to come away with only one gold, against a field that did not include any of the main American contenders for the World Championships, was surely a little disappointing. 

I wonder if it was all about the gymnasts?  I think some of the E scores were rather harsh - particularly the one for Grishina's floor qualification (7.675) which along with her lower D score of 5.7 led her to position behind Romania's Larissa Iordache, who had a fall.  With a composite of moderate deductions for a few smaller errors throughout the routine, Grishina ended up out of the final while other gymnasts progressed. 



She does not look as bad as her score to me.  However, I would question why a gymnast of Grishina's calibre would need to take such a long rest before her final tumble. 

You can find many more excellent videos at Piibunina's channel, including Grishina's beam routine (outstanding line, marred by two falls which apparently in both cases (Alexei Mikhailov advises) are caused by the positioning of the hands before the skill. Rodionova's bars are worth a look for the clear quality of the swing and line she shows - but does this gymnast have any competitive urges at all?

A disappointing outcome in Portugal for the Russian team, I think. Grishina and Rodionova both have the potential to do much better.

But if, as Boguinskaia says, Valentina Rodionenko is replacing their conditioning sets with a walk in the park and a cup of coffee, they never will do much better.

Saturday, June 22, 2013

Profile of a Russian gymnastics fan - Valeria



Valeria was sitting right next to me in the Olympiski Arena, Moscow, during the first day of the men's and women's event finals at the European Championships.  Her enthusiasm was infectious, her English excellent, and we soon got talking.  

I'm really curious to know what makes gymnastics fans tick, so asked Valeria a few questions.  She has some very interesting and well articulated opinions.






















Valeria, what would you like to say about yourself?

I'm 19 years old, live in Moscow, and study tourism management.   I love, of course, gym, cinema, travel. ))

How did you first become interested in gymnastics?

I became interested in gymnastics after watching the 2008 Beijing Olympics - in Russia, unfortunately, gymnastics is shown very rarely on the main channels, with poor commentators, so I was lucky to see it on cable TV, and I fell in love with gymnastics. :))

What is it about the sport that most excites you?

I like the gym for several reasons: it's beautiful, it's very risky, and could change at any moment.

I met you at the European Championships in Moscow this spring ... what was your highlight of that competition?


At the European Championships I liked best beam)   I love Larisa +)))

Do you attend competitions regularly? 

Only once, when we first met.  In Moscow, big gym is very rare.

Do you collect gymnastics memorabilia?

I collect gymnastic video - recording of old competitions, including regional, and load them into our social network vkontakte  ))

How do you follow all of the gymnastics news?

I watch the news on vkontakte - as well as the group there.) Here is the link - there are a lot of rare photos and video, maybe you would be interested.

Who are your favourite gymnasts and why?

My favourite gymnasts are Larisa Iordache, Jordyn Wieber, Aly Raisman, Simone Biles . I like them because they have very hard exercises.

Are you familiar with the great Soviet tradition of gymnastics of the past - the work of such gymnasts as Tourischeva, Yurchenko, Boguinskaia, Dityatin, Bilozerchev, Scherbo?

Of course, I know all the great Soviet gymnasts ))

Viktoria Komova, or Gabrielle Douglas?  Who do you prefer, and why?

For me clearly - Gabrielle Douglas. She is strong on all the exercises, while Komova emphasises the uneven bars.

What are your opinions of the Russian team?  Do you think they will be able to compete for gold at the next Olympics?

I like from the Russian teams Anastasia Grishina and Emin Garibov).  I think gold in the girls team is very little chance. America's team as a whole, is much stronger in complexity.

Are there any up and coming young Russian gymnasts who you would like to recommend we watch? 

Evgeniya Shelgunova) She is very talented.

What opinions do you have of the current Code of Points - any changes you would like to see?

I would like to see more encouraged to assess the difficulty, not performance. )


Thank you Valeria!!  I really loved Moscow, and our discussions, and hope you will continue to love gymnastics.


Would you like to tell readers about your experiences and thoughts as a gymnastics fan?  If so, please email me on rewriterussiagym@btinternet.com.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Russia announces teams for Universiade

Tatiana Nabieva will compete on vault and bars

Russian teams for the Universiade (gymnastics competitions take place 7th to 10th July) have been announced. Team format is 5-4-3 :

MAG : David Belyavski, Nikolai Kuksenkov, Denis Ablyazin, Emin Garibov, Mattei Petrov. Substitute - Nikita Ignatiev.

Women: Aliya Mustafina, Ksenia Afanasyeva, Tatiana Nabieva, Anna Dementieva, Maria Paseka

Kuksenkov has only just gained eligibility to compete for Russia and this will be his first international appearance for his new team.


Mustafina and Afanasyeva will compete all around. Nabieva has recovered from her injury and regained form and will be able to contribute on bars and vault, although she does not at present have a second vault.  If they want to win a medal on vault, they will have to take Maria Paseka. 

There is an interview with Valentina Rodionenko about the selection here.  It is clear that there is still some final decision making left to do before the teams travel to Kazan.

With thanks to Lifje for providing the information and link.

Monday, June 17, 2013

World class - but they never competed at a World Championships ...

They were brilliant, but did not make it to their final national teams for the World Championships, thanks to the sheer strength in depth of the Soviet team, or because they peaked too young.

Enjoy a few of the best gymnasts never seen at World level - perhaps you would like to suggest a few more of your own?

Yulia Kut, floor exercise, 1987



Nadezhda Ivanova, beam, 2004



Tatiana Kim, Floor, 1981



Alevtina Pryakhina, beam, 1986 - pity about that dismount



Irina Viatinina, floor, 1988



Ekaterina Vandisheva, beam, 1993





Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Alexandrov and Mustafina update: RGF confirms Alexandrov's departure


The RGF has now confirmed that Alexandrov has left Russia : thank you Laerke and Jennifer Ann for the link.
 




A brief summary of an interview with Valentina Rodionenko follows :


Alexandrov's contract as national coach terminated at the end of last year; his acting role as national team coach ceased at the end of October 2012, which is when he began to concentrate his efforts exclusively on coaching Aliya. Valentina stresses the main justification for this is that Alexandrov could not be team coach and personal coach to Aliya Mustafina at the same time. She also points out that at this spring's Europeans the team won six medals, compared to their poor showing at last year's Europeans when Russia lost to Romania by a significant margin.  Implicitly, therefore, she feels that the national team were underperforming under Alexandrov.  Aliya Mustafina's gold medal at the Olympics came on uneven bars, where she was coached by specialist (now team coach) Evgeny Grebyonkin.
Alexandrov has gone to America to be with his family there. He is a US citizen.
Valentina says that since last year, Alexandrov has become increasingly distant from Aliya and there have been communication difficulties. Alexander did not accompany Aliya to the podium in Europeans, and merely sat in the stands, observing her. Aliya has worked more and more with the apparatus specialists, and in the end wrote a letter asking for Alexandrov's role as her personal coach to be terminated.  Raisa Ganina is mentioned as a coach who has increasingly taken a hand in Aliya's coaching, with Grebyonkin. [Ed - Raisa accompanied Aliya on the podium in Moscow and has contributed to her coaching since her early days under Dina Kamalova.]
In another interview, Valentina says she is 'dissatisfied' with the way that this story has been reported in the press.  But I wasn't aware that there had been any press reports of this to date, apart from these transcripts of her interviews  ...
 

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Alexander Alexandrov to Brazil

RRG can confirm (with thanks to Vladimir Zaglada) that Alexander Alexandrov has now left Moscow (with effect from 1st June) and will be taking up a coaching position in Brazil as soon as the fine details are sorted out.

Patience please as we try to verify the exact details ... eyes peeled for Brazil or Russian press reports.

Aliya Mustafina fans, don't panic ... at 18, Aliya is very mature and she will learn from this experience.  The writing has been on the wall for some time.  This is a sad moment for Russian gymnastics, but it is also a new beginning for all concerned.

My very best wishes to Alexander as he begins his new life.

Sunday, June 2, 2013

Will the real Aliya Mustafina please step forward?

Not a fake profile ... Aliya's unofficial fanpage has over 50,000 followers

Have you seen the film Spartacus, the bit where the Romans try to get Spartacus to give himself up, but fail because there are so many people who claim to be him?

The gymnastics online community is getting a little bit like that ... I did some counting this morning on Facebook, having come across yet another online profile of a gymnast that claimed to be 'real' yet obviously wasn't :-)

22 online profiles of Aliya Mustafina
29 of Viktoria Komova

Some of these are athlete pages that present news of the gymnast's progress, but many are simply fake identities that make use of personal photographs found elsewhere on the internet to develop whole new narratives of the gymnast's life.  I love my regular Gin O'Clock updates of HRH the Queen's daily life as much as the next person, but these profiles try to pretend to be the real Aliya or Vika, without the embellishment of humour or even a courtesy acknowledgement of the sources used.  I don't think any harm is meant ... but I would feel violated if somebody else grabbed my private pictures and began to pretend they were an online version of me ...

Interestingly, though I thought there might be similar counts for other gymnasts, the vast majority of the 'fakes' seems to be on these two.  Perhaps the English language speaking gymnasts have more opportunity to keep their identities private. I also think that these two - highly professional sports stars - deserve more official help in sensitively policing and promoting their online social media presence.